Forensic Sciences


Collection and Preservation of DNA Evidence

Article Number: KJU074891 Volume 03 | Issue 01 | April - 2020 ISSN: 2581-4273
05th Mar, 2020
26th Mar, 2020
06th Apr, 2020
21st Apr, 2020

Authors

Govind Khanna, Kratika Mishra, Dr. Ranjeet Kumar Singh

Abstract

As the justice system or courts have more relay on DNA evidence in the last few years, the early steps in the examination of DNA evidence played a major role in the investigation. There is a need for proper collection and preservation of DNA evidence such as in sexual assault cases. This evidence played an important role in the personal identification of the victim and perpetrator or suspect. The importance of evidence preservation and collection is often revealed many difficult court challenges. In the identification, the forensic scientist tries to establish the link between victims, perpetrators with the scene of the crime. Now, to narrow down the aspect for identity, DNA evidence needs a proper collection and preservation because from this evidence we can extract a lot of essential information that helps in solving crimes and also provide a lead in case findings. This paper focuses on the techniques and methods to collect DNA traces. There is not so much research available on, but some studies reveal information and played a weighty role in the field of forensic science. This paper review those studies which give efforts in the collection and preservation of DNA evidence. Keywords: DNA Evidence, Collection, Preservation, Scene of Crime

Introduction

The DNA specimen plays a very important role in cases such as sexual assault, homicide, mass disaster, missing person identification, etc. Though, the achievement for a forensic laboratory examiner is depended on the condition of the evidence, if the DNA evidence is in a good condition then the maximum chances of a successful DNA profiling takes place. But if the collection and preservation of the evidence are not in an appropriate way then the DNA evidence might be able to give better results. All the biological evidence is at a risk of deterioration which results in microbial growth and this occurs due to environmental conditions. So, careful storage, collection, and preservation are important to obtain useful information for DNA analysis. A standard operating procedure is required for DNA collection and preservation in several types of the scene of crime and these procedures should be followed by medical doctors and investigation officers in the course of a criminal investigation. The DNA material is generally extracted from the biological samples. The biological samples from which DNA material is extracted and analyzed are such as blood and bloodstains, tissues and cells, hair with follicles, semen and seminal stains, bones and organs, saliva, etc. In case of bite marks the saliva is present on the person’s clothing or skin. Blood, saliva, hair, sweat, vaginal fluid, and semen can be found on the pillow, bed cover, blanket, etc. in rape cases. In the crime scene investigation, DNA evidence plays a very important role, it helps in connecting the victim and perpetrator with the crime scene and helps in legal proceedings. And it also helps in the reconstruction of the crime scene and supports the statement given by perpetrators or suspects, victims, and eyewitnesses. The collection of evidence should take place step by step by the field investigator at the scene of the crime (Lee & Pagliaro, 2013).

The priorities of an investigator are to discovering the evidence, recognizing the evidence, examining the evidence, collecting the evidence, recording the evidence, identifying the evidence, and packaging and storing of the evidence, present the evidence in the court of law. To avoid the contamination proper handling of the evidence should take place at the crime scene investigation. The main purpose of the DNA evidence is to provide useful information that helps in connecting the perpetrator or suspect and victim with the scene of crime. Every scene of crime is unique. There is a need for proper marking, sealing, and packaging of evidence at the time of collection of evidence. After that send the evidence to the forensic science laboratory. The work of a forensic scientist starts from the scene of crime with evidence recognition and recovery. Sometimes the evidence left by the suspect at the scene of crime. After the collection of the evidence, they have to be properly analyzed in the laboratories. DNA evidence also helps in revealing the information related to corpus delicti, modus operandi, connecting or linking the perpetrator with the victim and weapon, helps in disproving or supporting the testimony given by the witness, helps in a personal identification of the suspect, proving a lead in the investigation. Blood is an important piece of evidence that is found on the scene of crime and it can be found on surfaces such as vehicle, weapon, soil, cloth, dead body, windows, wall, etc. If blood is found in the form of liquid at the scene of crime, then with the help of dropper collect the blood and stored in plastic or glass bottle after adding the suitable anticoagulant i.e. EDTA. And stored the blood evidence in dark and cool places because it gets destroyed in heat or when directly exposed to light. The semen preservation is always taking place after drying the semen stain completely. In case if semen stain is wet the chances of bacterial growth are possible and due to the protein present in semen, the stage of putrefaction may also occur. The semen preservation is always taking place in airbag, not in a plastic bag or airtight bag. If stain was found on a small article, preserved the entire article and send the sample in a forensic science laboratory. If semen stain is present on an immovable object, then with the help of a scalpel or sharp knife scratch the semen stain and packaged in a clean bottle of glass. A clean plastic tube or bag is also used in the preservation when a semen stain is present on the public hair. When the semen stain is present on any part of the body than with the help of cotton swab and saline water the stain can be collected. Do not touch the sample with bare hands because it results in contamination of the sample or sometimes it can have destroyed the evidence (https://www.epgp.inflibnet.ac.in).

In biological samples, DNA played a vital role in acute sexual assault (ASA) cases which help in establishing the incidence of sexual interaction and also helps in the identification of the suspect. There are the techniques which are used to collect the DNA evidence,

One Swab – It is a quick technique but this technique does not give a guarantee in collecting the whole evidence for analysis in the laboratory. It is mainly used when the evidence is present in limited quantity

Two Swab – This technique is applied when there is abundant biological sample is present such as in cases where direct ejaculation was found in the vaginal cavity and this technique is only applicable to post pubertal victims. In this technique, the specimen is quickly collected and permits the usage of the second swab for counterproof.

Two Swabs Successively – This is also known as the double swab technique, it is the application of two successive swabs, and the first one is the wet whose target is to gather the evidence in the majority and the second one is a dry swab. This method has aimed to collect evidence in an abundant amount. It is not a rapid technique and there is no such guarantee of two swabs equality, the second swab can have evidence in a lower concentration. After having limitations, this technique is widely used for the purpose of the collection of numerous types of biological specimens (Magalhães et al., 2015).

To get the maximum information about the DNA profile from the biological samples collected from the scene of the crime, use a device that gives more significant results. This is vital to preserving from degradation and pollutants to maintain the integrity of the biological sample which helps in DNA analysis. So to make a successful DNA profile, the sample is not relaid completely on the laboratory examination processes but also depends on the sampling methods applied by the investigator at the scene of crime. Several types of collection methods are available such as FTA paper scraping, cutting method, scraping the surface with the help of a wooden applicator stick, taping, dry or wet, double or single swabbing, vacuum sampling. Swabbing is the maximum used versatile method. It is helpful in the collection of DNA samples which is used by both the forensic laboratory examiner and crime scene investigator. So, as a result, there is an increase in the swab type’s methods, they are available in the markets. There are several studies conducted on the swabs and the swabbing conditions and questions are always arising on the institutions that the swabs methods are still suitable, whether they are giving good scientific results or not. There are some swabs that are used in the collection of DNA traces from different items. The swabs such as Puritan FAB-MINI-AP, COPAN 4N6FLOQ Swabs (Genetic variety), and Sarstedt Forensic Swab are used for the purpose of DNA traces collection (Comte et al., 2019).

References

“Forensic Evidence and Crime Scene Investigation.” Journal of Forensic Investigation, vol. 01, no. 02, 2013, doi:10.13188/2330-0396.1000004.

Aloraer, D., et al. “Collection Protocols for the Recovery of Biological Samples.” Forensic Science International: Genetics Supplement Series, vol. 5, 2015, doi:10.1016/j.fsigss.2015.09.083.

Cătălin, Marian, et al. “Modern Methods of Collection and Preservation of Biological Evidence for Human Identification by DNA Analysis.” Docplayer, Accessed on 3rd March 2020. Available at: www.docplayer.net/14538322-Modern-methods-of-collection-and-preservation-of-biological-evidence-for-human-identification-by-dna-analysis.html.

Comte, Jennifer, et al. “Touch DNA Collection – Performance of Four Different Swabs.” Forensic Science International: Genetics, vol. 43, 2019, p. 102113. doi:10.1016/j.fsigen.2019.06.014.

Garvin, Alex M., et al. “The ForensiX Evidence Collection Tube and Its Impact on DNA Preservation and Recovery.” BioMed Research International, vol. 2013, 2013, pp. 1-7., doi:10.1155/2013/105797.

Lee, Ladd C., et al. “Forensic Applications of DNA Typing: Collection and Preservation of DNA Evidence.” American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology, vol. 19, 1998, pp. 10-18.,

Lee, Ladd. “Evidence Collection and Preservation: A Review on Preservation and Collection of Biological Evidence.” Croatian Medical Journal, vol. 42, 2001, pp. 225-228, 2001.

Magalhães, Teresa, et al. “Biological Evidence Management for DNA Analysis in Cases of Sexual Assault.” The Scientific World Journal, vol. 2015, 2015, pp. 1-11., doi:10.1155/2015/365674.

Palmbach, Timothy, et al. “Utilizing DNA Analysis to Combat the World Wide Plague of Present Day Slavery – Trafficking in Persons.” Croatian Medical Journal, vol. 55, no. 1, 2014, pp. 3–8., doi:10.3325/cmj.2014.55.3.

How to cite this article?

APA StyleKhanna, G., Singh, R. K., & Mishra, K. (2020). Collection and Preservation of DNA Evidence. Academic Journal of Forensic Sciences, 3(1), 07–11.
Chicago Style
MLA Style
DOI
URL

Create Your Password

We've sent a link to create password on your registered email, Click the link in email to start using Xournal.

Sign In

Forgot Password?
Don't have an account? Create Account

Create Account

Already have an account? Sign In

Forgot Password

Do you want to try again? Sign In

Publication Tracking